The Baby and the Bath Water
Monday, June 29th, 2009We human beings, with the best of intentions, often do stupid things. Especially in moments of revolution, we find it easy to throw out the baby with the bath water. And then we fail to notice that something of value is getting lost in our zeal for reform.
It happened to the Marxists of the last century, who somehow threw out human rights in order to save human rights. Never did fully figure that one out. It happens regularly to liberal Protestants, who in seeking to reform the church, sometimes react to symbols that have been used oppressively by wanting to chuck the symbol as well as the oppression. For example, I run into liberal congregations who have developed allergies to talking about Jesus, as if Jesus is nothing more than the JEEsus of TV preachers and the Pentecostal mega-church circa 1978.
Now the same phenomenon is happening with the emergent generation of young adult church leaders, many of whom see no reason to retain the concept of church membership. Of course, the old bath water that they want to chuck is cheap membership that means nothing, the practice of clubby Christianity, and hyper-focus on organizational affiliation to the neglect of following Jesus. Again and again, I hear young leaders dismiss the value of church membership, as if it is a dinosaur, going the way of the Kiwanis Club. They see membership as the symbol of all that went wrong with their parent’s church. (more…)